Menu 

St. Elmo’s Steakhouse Restaurant in Indianapolis, Indiana: Stylish Steaks and More

St. Elmo’s Restaurant Reviews and Comments

A restaurant can build up quite a solid fan base over a century of service. People love St. Elmo’s Restaurant in Indianapolis‘ suave and swanky downtown district so much that they’ll travel long distances to get there, and once there, St. Elmo’s fans are reluctant to leave. Customer comments and reviews are, therefore, almost entirely excellent. See some of them below. To read the complete review posted by the customer, just click the link above the review you’re interested in.

St. Elmo’s Restaurant
St. Elmo’s Restaurant Reviews and Comments
St. Elmo’s Restaurant Photos and Videos

St. Elmo’s Restaurant in Indianapolis, Indiana
Restaurant Reviews and Restaurant Comments

Try the Shrimp Cocktail!
If you are looking for steak in Indy skip the chains and head straight here. The steaks were excellent and prepared to the correct temperature. Don’t miss the shrimp cocktail with the hottest horseradish (freshly grated) cocktail sauce we’ve ever had…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Perfection
The steaks melt in your mouth. The non-steak dishes are done to perfection, as well. I’ve had trout and perch here, and both were the best I’ve ever had. The service is professional and incredibly attentive without being overbearing…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Consistent
Been to St. Elmo 8 times over the last 15 years on business; consistently good, sometimes great; awesome shrimp cocktail has seen shrimps shrunken over time though; drinks always great as is service; great wine list; watchout for long waits during conventions – go early.
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

The Best
Simply Indy’s best. Shrimp cocktail with the hotest horseradish known to mankind, a wedge of lettuce with blue cheese dressing and a think steak.
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Excellent
While standard steakhouse fare, the food was excellent with the fresh horsradish laden shrimp cocktail being a real treat. Decor was excellent, and while the wine list was thurough, was disappointed that original pick was out of stock…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Best steak ever
We arrived at a VERY crowded restaurant yet we were seated at our reserved table quickly. We were very fortunate to also have David as our server – the service was perfect…!! We ordered the shrimp cocktail and then filet mignon with the bone in… It was the best steak I have ever tasted…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

The place to go
If you’re in Indy and want one of the best steaks you’ll ever have, this is the place to go. This was my second time at Elmo’s and my wife’s first. We had the bone-in filet and Rick, our server, recommended adding some of the fried shrimp on the side which was perfect. Nice jumbo, butterflied shrimp…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Noisy but exceptional
Our group of 8 was placed in a private room. However, we shared it with a group of 11 that had arrived before us. We were not able to share conversation except with our direct neighbors until food arrived for the “competing” party. I have been in the same room previously with a business group and it was perfect. This was the Indy 500 weekend and the restaurant was apparently “doubling up” for the crowd. Food and service were exceptional…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Do not miss the Shrimp Cocktail!
Food was very good to excellent. Be careful about which steak you order…those with bones in are not consistently cooked throughout…starts out overdone and then gets much more rare towards bone. Filet seems to be outstanding every time. Shrimp cocktail is unique and a must-have. You must try it at least once.
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

A must experience
Excellent as always. Consistent over the last 20 years I have been going there. Always a pleasure to dine there. A must experience for anyone when they are in downtown Indianapolis.

Local gem
This is a local gem and a great place to enjoy their famous Shrimp cocktail with fresh horseradish sauce 🙂 Great steaks as well! The service staff are attentive and are always more than happy to attend to all your requests and needs! A must go to restaurant in Indianapolis! You will not be disappointed! Highly recommend you make reservations…
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

Great special occasion place
Outstanding food with good service. Although expensive, great for special occasions and a must do when you are in Indy
(This review is the opinion of an actual customer who visited the restaurant, not of FunCityFinder.)

St. Elmo’s Restaurant | St. Elmo’s Restaurant Reviews and Comments | St. Elmo’s Restaurant Photos and Video


Indianapolis Downtown Restaurants

Agio’s Restaurant and Bar | Eagles Nest Indianapolis Restaurant | R Bistro Restaurant | More Indianapolis Downtown Restaurants

Indianapolis Restaurants

Indianapolis Downtown Restaurants | Indianapolis North Restaurants | Indianapolis Northeast Restaurants | Indianapolis Northwest Restaurants | Indianapolis West Restaurants | Indianapolis Southwest Restaurants | Indianapolis East Restaurants | Indianapolis Southeast Restaurants | Indianapolis South Restaurants

Indiana Restaurants by City

Anderson Restaurants | Avon Restaurants | Bargersville Restaurants | Brownsburg Restaurants | Camby Restaurants | Carmel Restaurants | Cicero Restaurants | Crawfordsville Restaurants | Danville Restaurants | Fishers Restaurants | Fortville Restaurants | Greencastle Restaurants | Greenfield Restaurants | Greenwood Restaurants | Indianapolis Restaurants | Lawrence Restaurants | Lebanon Restaurants | Martinsville Restaurants | Mooresville Restaurants | Noblesville Restaurants | Plainfield Restaurants | Shelbyville Restaurants | Westfield Restaurants | Zionsville Restaurants | More Indiana Restaurants

Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine

American Cuisine Restaurants |Barbecue Restaurants | Cajun Restaurants | Chinese Restaurants | Delicatessen Restaurants | German Restaurants | Irish Restaurants | Italian Restaurants | Japanese Restaurants | Korean Restaurants | Mexican Restaurants | Pizza Restaurants | Seafood Restaurants | Steakhouses Restaurants | Thai Restaurants | More Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine

Pages: 1 2 3