Menu 

Christmas at the Mystery Cafe Celebrates the Holidays with Mayhem

Solve a mystery this holiday season with Christmas at the Mystery Cafe, Indianapolis theatre’s favorite dinner mystery theatre! A thrilling evening of mystery, adventure and delicious dinner, what better way to spend some quality time with the family than at an outlandishly fun Indianapolis arts event such as Christmas at the Mystery Cafe? Tickets for this Indianapolis event are $46.50, which includes both dinner and the show.

New Year’s Evil is the name of the game. It is New Year’s Eve in a little town known only as Has-Been, Colorado, where celebrity has-beens flee from their failures at fame. Wally Wannabe (a rich promoter and Gilligan’s Island fanatic) and Selma Booty (a Top 100 Rock Star Groupie and spokes girl for Gutbusters), host a host of has-beens at the Falling Star Lodge. But a group of environmental activists threaten the fun as they protest Wally’s construction of the Has-Been Hall of Flames. When Wally gets more than bubbles in his champagne, Detective Nick Saint is on the case with some 1940s flair. In this hilarious whodunit, everyone is a suspect including Mr. T-Bone, Rue McCanaham, Richard Chamberpot, Eric Enchilada, Suzanne Summers Over, Rosie McDonalds, Quincy Bones, Whitney Houstoned, Bobby Brown-Out, Jerry Smathers and many many more.

Identifying the guilty party before the ball drops at midnight might be too big of a job for the down and out Nick Saint. As he tries to lay off the booze and find the bad guy, time ticks on. For a hilarious night of mayhem and fun, help solve a Christmas mystery at the Mystery Cafe. Arrive at the “scene of the crime,” and once the guests are seated, dinner and the show begin. Eat a delicious meal as the actors perform an interactive mystery play. Audience participation is a must!

This Indianapolis restaurant/theatre serves up some fun and a four course meal. With minestrone soup, tossed salad, and your choice of lasagna, shells Florentine, chicken Parmesan or sausage cannelloni, this meal is fit for a king. Plus fresh bread served throughout and spumoni as the mystery wraps up. Wear your costumes to this 1940s themed mystery for a full experience. For more information about Christmas at The Mystery Cafe, visit their website. Help solve the case of New Year’s Evil before another has-been is knocked off of the reality television circuit.

For all the latest on Indianapolis art and other fun things to do in Indianapolis, stay tuned to Fun City Finder.com. After the show, check out these great Indianapolis bars as you continue your holiday celebrations. This holiday season let Fun City Finder.com be you source for fun in Indy. Let us bring the Circle City to life for you and yours.

New Year’s Evil
Christmas at the Mystery Cafe
Now through January 2

The Mystery Cafe at the Milano Inn
231 S College Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46202
317.684.0668