Best Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana

Indianapolis, Indiana Italian restaurants are abundant, authentic and absolutely irresistible. The many ethnic Indianapolis restaurants evidence the wonderful diversity that made Indiana strong. As everybody knows, home really is where the kitchen is, and in the very special Indianapolis Italian restaurants, that inevitably spells amore.

Take a look at the great Italian restaurants in Indianapolis listed in the chart below. Follow the links to see detailed articles and photos about their Old World cuisine, their service and their ambiance.

Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana

Amalfi Ristorante: This is one of three Italian restaurants in Indianapolis run by the talented Dirosa family. Here you will find some of the best Italian food in the Midwest. Amalfi fan’s favorites on this North Italy menu include the house Veal Piccata and Potato Dumplings. 
Ambrosia Restaurant: Upscale and traditional, this restaurant in Indianapolis‘ north side also sports some very palatable prices. Devotees of the Ambrosia Restaurant often rave about the Calamari, the spinach and cheese stuffed Ravioli, and the Tortellini.
Amici’s Italian Restaurant: Offering first-rate Italian food in an intimate, candlelit setting right in the middle of bustling downtown Indianapolis , Amici’s is reportedly the oldest Italian restaurant in all of greater Indianapolis. Well-known for their Puttanesca Pizza, Mushroom Crostini and Shrimp Diavlo.
Augustino’s Italian Restaurant: Serving up everything from Fettuccini Alfredo to Spaghetti and Meatballs, Augustino’s has racked up tons of fans who swear by their mouth-watering Italian dishes and abundant portions.
Buca di Beppo: Here is a favorite among the many great Indianapolis restaurants downtown. Portions are so large they give the customers oversized spoons. Try their specialty pastas, pizzas or meatballs the size of a fist, and accompany your Buca Italian feast with a tumbler of Chianti.
Capri Ristorante: The Dirosa family brings Old World recipes to Indy at this popular Northeast Indianapolis restaurant. Some of the house specialties include the Linguine with fresh clams, the Tortellino and their signature Ravioli Aurora.
Charbonos Restaurant: Charbonos is a Tuscan-themed restaurant voted Most Romantic in Hendricks County several years in a row. This lovely restaurant in Avon, a suburb of Indianapolis, offers a long and varied menu with items such as Linguini, Penne Pasta with chicken and sausage and Chicken Scaloppini. Many all-American favorites are on the menu as well.
Iaria’s Italian Restaurant: Since 1933, this excellent Italian restaurant in Indianapolis has been producing authentic Italian dishes such as their renowned Fettuccini with clam sauce, seafood pasta and Veal Parmesan in a spicy marsala marinade.
Lorenzano’s Family Ristorante: East Indy’s go-to Italian restaurant is Lorenzano’s, an unprepossessing dining room the Indianapolis Star called a “hidden gem.” Located close to Indy suburb Beech Grove, Lorenzano’s is well-known for their Hot Italian Stew, Ravioli and Spaghetti and Italian Sausage specialties.
Maggiano’s Little Italy Restaurant: Right in the midst of busy Fashion Mall at Keystone Crossing, Maggiano’s brings a flavor of Old World atmosphere and cuisine to the northeast corner of Indianapolis, from their Lobster Fettucine to the Angel Hair al Arrabiata and the house ChickenPesto.
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant: This restaurant in North Indianapolis is often described as a romantic date place in Indianapolis, but they’re well-equipped to handle large groups too. Try Mama’s Chicken Rigatoni or traditional Beef Lasagna.
Mangia Italian Restaurant: This dining establishment, in upscale Indy suburb Carmel, Indiana, has accumulated a number of awards for its authentic menu from northern Italy. Fans rave about the Baked Portobello al Forno and Calamari appetizers, the Gamberi alla Griglia shrimp and the Penne Pasta alla Vodka.
Matteo’s Ristorante Italiano: Recently opened, this authentic Italian restaurant in Noblesville is well worth a short drive from the center of the Circle City. Along with traditional recipes from the family homeland in Naples, such as Veal Scallopini and Chicken Cacciatore, you can also find a sumptuous Filet Mignon at Matteo’s.
Milano Inn: Downtown’s culinary landmark since 1934, the Milano Inn Italian Restaurant serves savory Old World dishes like Shrimp Parmiagiana and Fettucine Alfredo inside a plush, warm restaurant that is now a happy part of Indianapolis history.
Napoli Villa Italian Restaurant: In greater Indianapolis, there are few Italian restaurants to rival Napoli’s, located in the suburb called Beech Grove, which is tucked away in the southeast corner of Indy. Favorite dishes from the Napoli Villa Italian Restaurant include the Chicken Marsala, Veal Caruso and the house Antipasto Salad.
Sangiovese Restaurant: Another jewel of a restaurant in Northeast Indianapolis, Sangiovese is a gathering place for lovers of the finer things in life, such as art and live jazz music in Indianapolis, along with memorable Italian cuisine. The house Spaghetti Fra Diavlo and Lasagna are just two of many Sangiovese favorites.
Vito Provolone’s Restaurant: This cozy Italian restaurant just five miles south of Indy’s southern border serves authentic Italian fare and is a family-owned fixture in the neighborhood, bringing the taste and heritage of Italy to the Midwest. Be sure to try their Chicken Giovanni.

Indianapolis Restaurants

Indianapolis Downtown Restaurants | Indianapolis North Restaurants | Indianapolis Northeast Restaurants | Indianapolis Northwest Restaurants | Indianapolis West Restaurants | Indianapolis Southwest Restaurants | Indianapolis East Restaurants | Indianapolis Southeast Restaurants | Indianapolis South Restaurants

Indiana Restaurants by City

Anderson Restaurants | Avon Restaurants | Bargersville Restaurants | Brownsburg Restaurants | Camby Restaurants | Carmel Restaurants | Cicero Restaurants | Crawfordsville Restaurants | Danville Restaurants | Fishers Restaurants | Fortville Restaurants | Greencastle Restaurants | Greenfield Restaurants | Greenwood Restaurants | Indianapolis Restaurants | Lawrence Restaurants | Lebanon Restaurants | Martinsville Restaurants | Mooresville Restaurants | Noblesville Restaurants | Plainfield Restaurants | Shelbyville Restaurants | Westfield Restaurants | Zionsville Restaurants | More Indiana Restaurants

Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine

American Cuisine Restaurants |Barbecue Restaurants | Cajun Restaurants | Chinese Restaurants | Delicatessen Restaurants | German Restaurants | Irish Restaurants | Italian Restaurants | Japanese Restaurants | Korean Restaurants | Mexican Restaurants | Pizza Restaurants | Seafood Restaurants | Steakhouses Restaurants | Thai Restaurants | More Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine

Fun City Finder wants to hear your thoughts! If you’ve tried any of these restaurants, please let us know how you liked them by putting your comments in the submission box below.