Play It Again Sports: Sporting Equipment For Everyone!

play-it-again-sportsIf you’re tired of dealing with the high prices and unknowledgeable staff that accompany shopping at one those major chain sporting goods stores, Play It Again Sports in Carmel, Indiana, offers an excellent alternative.  Featuring new sporting goods and fitness equipment from major brand name manufacturers, AND high-quality used gear and equipment, Play It Again Sports should be the first choice of any Indianapolis sports participant — or parent of a participant.

Located on the northwest corner of the 116th street and Keystone Avenue intersection, PIAS has been in Carmel for nearly 20 years, and has been under current ownership for the past eight.  Although it is individually owned and operated, the Carmel store is one of 400+ Play It Again Sports across the nation, which gives it not only the buying power to carry a slew of different new products, but the ability to offer the most competitive sporting good prices in all of Indianapolis.  And we’re not talking about off-brand and no-name equipment either — they carry  all the top brands including, Callaway, TaylorMade, Nike, Adidas, Horizon Fitness, Nike Bauer, Easton and many, many more.

In addition to new products, Play It AgainSports also buys, sells, and trades high-quality used gear.  For instance, every parent who’s had a kid playing in youth sports knows the outrageous rate the little fella’s grow out of their equipment.  Nearly every year — and sometimes twice a year — kids need new stuff.  Instead of letting the still useable gear collect cobwebs in the garage, you can trade it into Play It Again Sports, and in return receive cash or store credit to purchase new equipment, greatly cutting down the cost of outfitting Junior for whatever sport he or she is playing that particular season.

Here’s a look at what you can find inside this locally owned Indianapolis business.

Whether you prefer training on an elliptical…


A treadmill…


Or a stationary bicycle…


Play It Again Sports has numerous ways for you to get your cardio fix.


For you body building types, there are plenty of top-notch weight lifting equipment to choose from.


With weights ranging from 2.5lbs up to 100lbs, and a plethora of different sized Kettlebells, it doesn’t matter if you’re an ardent P90X follower, or a disciple of the Jillian Michaels school of weight loss, they have what you need.



Don’t let the sign confuse you, the weights aren’t really free, but at just $0.59 per pound for a used plate, you won’t find a cheaper price anywhere in Indy.


As you can see, they also carry heavy bags, squat racks, home gyms, and pretty much anything else you’ll need to get in tip-top shape.


If it’s team sports you’re into, Play It Again Sports has you covered.


And there’s plenty of options if you’re more into individual sports as well…


Just a small sampling of the tennis section, which has racquets for the smallest of beginners, to the most competitive adult players.


With hundreds of drivers, putters, wedges and iron sets consisting of pro-line clubs, Play It Again is a great place for golfers of all skill levels to visit.


Many golf enthusiasts are putting down their clubs in favor of a disc.  With courses set up at Sahm Golf Course, and James A. Dillon Park in Noblesville, Indiana, there are plenty of places to play disc golf in the area.


Aside from all the great gear and equipment, Play It Again Sports also distinguishes itself by its extremely friendly and knowledgeable staff, and its support and participation within the Carmel communityPlay It Again Sports in Carmel has been named a Gold Standard Store by achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations, and Customer Service. Visit their website at

So what are you waiting for?  If you’re in need of anything sporting goods related, make sure you head on up to Carmel and visit the guys at Play It Again Sports.  You’re guaranteed to leave with a smile on your face.


Play It Again Sports Carmel
271 Merchants Square Drive
(just WEST of MARSH at 116th & KEYSTONE)
Carmel, IN 46032


M-F: 10Am-7PM

Saturday: 10AM-6PM

Sunday: 12PM-5PM

Indianapolis Businesses

25 Largest Private Indianapolis Companies | 50 Largest Private Indiana Companies | 25 Largest Public Indianapolis Companies | 50 Largest Public Indiana Companies | More About Indianapolis Businesses

Indiana Businesses by City

Avon Business | Brownsburg Business | Carmel Businesses | Danville Business | Fishers Business | Franklin Business | Greenfield Business | Greenwood Business | Martinsville Business | Mooresville Business | Noblesville Business | Plainfield Business | Westfield Business | Zionsville Business | More About Indiana Business